Follow us on:
We provides comprehensive legal services to builders, developers, and construction companies, ensuring compliance with property laws, resolving disputes, and facilitating seamless real estate transactions. KHA ADVOCATES specializes in offering end-to-end legal support for real estate projects, from land acquisition to project completion.
: One Book Consultation Form is available in out website, click on the button to open the form.
Fillup the Form carefully with all relevant details which helps us to serve you in a better way.
In the form there is an exclusive option to select date and time of meeting of your choice as per your convenience.
After submission the form, the Client Relationship Officer (CRO) will contact you to verify all the submitted details and finally schedule an one to one meeting with the Legal Head.
With a strong reputation among developers, we ensure transparency, timely execution, and strategic legal advice tailored to the real estate sector.
KHA ADVOCATES brings deep knowledge and hands-on experience in Real Estate law and regulatory frameworks, ensuring reliable legal counsel.
From land purchase to final handover, KHA ADVOCATES provides continuous legal support throughout the project lifecycle.
We believe in building long-term relationships with our developer clients, ensuring continuity, strategic planning, and complete confidentiality of your projects and deals.
We offer flexible fee structures, retainers, and project-based billing suitable for businesses of all sizes — with scalable legal services as you grow.
Our client-centric approach ensures honest advice, timely execution, and complete transparency throughout the process.
Dive into our blog for the latest insights, tips, and trends. Stay informed and inspired by our expert articles on various topics that matter to you.
🏗️ IntroductionIn a landmark decision that strengthens consumer rights, the Supreme Court of India has ruled that builders cannot deduct more than 10% of the total flat cost when a buyer cancels the booking. The judgment comes as a relief to countless homebuyers who have faced unfair deductions from real estate developers during cancellations. This ruling sets a powerful precedent and aligns with the principles of fairness and reasonableness under Indian contract and consumer protection law.Background: Why This Issue MattersOver the years, many homebuyers have reported instances where real estate developers deducted 20%, 25%, or even 30% of the total property value when a buyer decided to cancel the booking, often without starting construction or incurring any loss.This unfair trade practice prompted legal intervention, and the judiciary has now taken a stand to protect buyers from arbitrary contract clauses that are heavily biased in favour of builders.Supreme Court Ruling: Key HighlightsIn the case of Wg. Cdr. Arifur Rahman Khan & Ors. v. DLF Southern Homes Pvt. Ltd., the Supreme Court upheld the consumer-friendly interpretation that if the builder has not incurred a substantial loss or started construction, they cannot deduct more than 10% of the booking amount or flat price.Important Takeaways:Maximum Deduction Limit: Builders can deduct no more than 10% in case of cancellation.Beyond 10% is arbitrary and amounts to unjust enrichment.Unilateral terms in builder-buyer agreements that allow excessive deductions are unconscionable and voidable.The builder cannot use delay tactics or unjust contract terms to deny fair refunds.⚖️ Legal Reasoning: Supreme Court’s AnalysisThe Court based its ruling on several legal principles:Principle of Unconscionable ContractsWhen one party (the builder) has excessive bargaining power, the Court can strike down oppressive terms.Citing Central Inland Water Transport Corporation v. Brojo Nath, the Court emphasized that contractual terms must be reasonable and fair.Consumer Protection ActThe Court reaffirmed that a buyer is a consumer and entitled to just treatment under Sections 2(1)(d) & 2(1)(r) of the Consumer Protection Act.Builders indulging in excessive deduction are guilty of unfair trade practices.Doctrine of ReasonablenessBuilders are not permitted to make windfall gains from cancellations.Refund policy must reflect actual losses, not speculative penalties.Other Important Judgments on the SubjectKailash Nath Associates v. DDA [(2015) 4 SCC 136]The Court held that forfeiture of earnest money is only valid if the party has suffered a loss. Builders must prove actual damage for withholding more than 10%.Haryana Urban Development Authority v. Dropadi DeviOnly reasonable forfeiture is allowed. Excessive deduction without justification is illegal.RERA Provisions – Section 18 of RERA Act, 2016The buyer is entitled to full refund with interest if the builder fails to deliver on time. Deductions exceeding 10% are in direct conflict with RERA’s spirit.What It Means for HomebuyersIf you have cancelled your flat booking and the builder is withholding more than 10%, you have a strong legal remedy. The following steps are advised:📋 What You Can Do:Send a legal notice seeking full refund minus 10%.File a complaint with the Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA).Approach Consumer Court if builder refuses or delays refund.Maintain booking receipts, payment records, and correspondence as evidence.Precautionary Measures for Future BuyersRead the Builder-Buyer Agreement thoroughly before signing.Negotiate clauses related to cancellation and refund.Prefer builders registered under RERA with transparent refund policies.Get legal vetting of the agreement from a property lawyer.How KHA Advocates Can HelpAt KHA Advocates, we assist homebuyers in fighting against builder malpractices, securing rightful refunds, and filing RERA and consumer complaints. Our team of real estate and litigation experts ensures your legal rights are protected.📞 Book a Consultation: https://khaadvocates.com/book-consultation🏢 Representing clients in Supreme Court, High Courts, RERA & Consumer ForumsConclusionThe Supreme Court’s ruling offers much-needed relief and clarity to homebuyers. By capping the builder’s deduction at 10%, the Court has reaffirmed the principle that contracts cannot override fairness and public interest. Homebuyers must remain informed, vigilant, and assertive in asserting their rights.
Read More
IntroductionSalt Lake City, officially known as Bidhannagar, was conceptualized and developed under the leadership of Dr. Bidhan Chandra Roy, the then Chief Minister of West Bengal. Conceived as a modern satellite township adjacent to Kolkata, the project involved the acquisition of wetlands and privately owned lands. These lands were subsequently allotted to individuals through lease agreements, each extending up to an unprecedented 999 years—ensuring government control while granting long-term occupancy rights.Initially, allotments were conducted through a lottery system. However, with time, the issue of property transfers within Salt Lake arose. The restrictive nature of lease deeds and the absence of a clear legal mechanism for transferring leasehold rights led many lessees to opt for unofficial means such as executing Powers of Attorney or Wills—resulting in a loss of revenue for the State.To address this issue and to establish legal clarity, the West Bengal government introduced a formal framework through a Gazette Notification in 2012. This article aims to provide a comprehensive and simplified explanation of the current legal position, procedures, and key judgments related to leasehold property transfers in Bidhannagar.Types of Lease Deeds in Salt LakeThe 17-Clause Lease DeedAmong the earliest lease agreements executed in the 1970s, the 17-Clause Lease Deed granted leaseholders more liberal terms, with no explicit restrictions on the transfer of property. Roughly 88 such deeds were issued to the first group of Salt Lake allottees.Due to the absence of any clause requiring government approval for transfer, leaseholders under this deed have historically enjoyed greater flexibility. Over the years, the Calcutta High Court has supported this interpretation, directing authorities to process mutations in favour of transferees without insisting on government permission.The 20-Clause Lease DeedUnlike the 17-Clause version, the 20-Clause Lease Deed contains specific restrictions that require prior approval from the Urban Development Department before any transfer of the leasehold property. These restrictive covenants are aimed at maintaining state oversight and regulating the sale of government-leased land.2012 Gazette Notification: Regulation of TransfersOn June 22, 2012, the West Bengal Government issued a Gazette Notification (No. 2709-SL(AL)/4S-9/2004(Pt-I)) introducing a formal transfer policy for leasehold plots in Bidhannagar. Key highlights include:Mandatory Government Approval: Transfer of leasehold rights requires prior permission from the Urban Development Department.Transfer Fee: A fee of ₹5,00,000 per cottah was introduced. However, exemptions apply for intra-family transfers (e.g., to parents or spouse).Regularization of Past Transfers: Past transactions conducted without government approval could be regularized upon payment of the transfer fee and completion of required formalities.Binding Lease Terms: All transfers are subject to the original lease terms, and the transferee inherits the obligations of the lease.This notification primarily targeted restrictive leasehold deeds (such as the 20-Clause Deed) but caused confusion regarding its applicability to 17-Clause Deeds.Landmark Judgment: State of West Bengal & Ors. vs. Ajay Poddar & Anr.This pivotal case resolved key ambiguities surrounding the 17-Clause Lease Deed. The issue before the Supreme Court was whether lessees holding 17-Clause Deeds could transfer their property without government approval or paying the transfer fee mandated in the 2012 notification.Supreme Court Ruling (March 11, 2015):The Apex Court ruled that the 17-Clause Deeds did not require government approval for transfers.The ₹5,00,000 per cottah transfer fee was deemed applicable only to restrictive lease deeds, such as those containing the 20 clauses.Past transfers executed without prior permission under 17-Clause Deeds were held valid, provided they complied with other legal requirements.Government agencies were directed to process mutations for such transfers without demanding approval or fees.This judgment provided significant relief to lessees and removed procedural bottlenecks for a large number of plot owners.2016 Circular: Simplification with ConditionsFollowing the Supreme Court judgment, the Urban Development Department issued Circular No. 693-UD/LM/SL(AL)-4S-5/2016 on May 4, 2016. This clarified the operational procedures for transferring 17-Clause Leasehold Plots:Prior Approval Not Required: Lessees need not seek permission from the government before transferring their plots.Mandatory Transfer Fee: Despite the removal of permission requirements, the transfer fee continues to apply—even for 17-Clause Deeds.Regularization of Past Transactions: Unauthorized transfers can be legalized upon payment of fees and proper documentation.This circular sought to balance ease of transactions with the state’s revenue interests and legal accountability.Step-by-Step Procedure to Buy Leasehold Plots in Salt Lake1. Document CollectionLease DeedAllotment LetterMutation Certificate (if applicable)Tax Clearance CertificateNo Objection Certificates (as applicable)2. Title Verification & Agreement PreparationConduct a thorough title search.Draft an “Agreement for Assignment of Lease” detailing sale price, terms, and responsibilities.3. Application for Transfer PermissionPrepare an application along with:Identity proof of buyer and sellerCertified copies of lease documentsAgreement for assignmentTax receipts and No Dues Certificate4. Online SubmissionRegister on the official portal of the Urban Development Authority.Upload notarized documents in PDF format (max 2MB each).Pay the application fee (currently ₹1,000).5. Verification ProcessAuthorities review documents and conduct physical inspection of the plot to match records.6. Hearing & Payment of Transfer FeeAttend the scheduled hearing with buyer, seller, and legal representatives.Pay the applicable transfer fee based on plot area.Submit draft deed for government approval.7. Deed RegistrationExecute and register the final Lease Transfer Deed at the designated registration office.The government issues a registration order upon approval.8. MutationSubmit the registered deed to the Urban Development Authority within 60 days.Apply for mutation to update ownership in official land records.Obtain a Mutation Certificate upon approval.ConclusionSalt Lake’s land transfer laws have evolved significantly since the township’s inception. The early liberal 17-Clause Lease Deeds offered flexibility, later reaffirmed by the Supreme Court, while the more regulated 20-Clause Deeds require strict compliance with transfer procedures.The 2012 notification and subsequent 2016 circular laid the groundwork for a structured and revenue-conscious framework. While these measures aimed to streamline transfers and reduce irregularities, practical challenges such as administrative delays and lack of public awareness continue to persist.Understanding the legal nuances and following proper procedures is crucial for any individual seeking to buy or transfer leasehold property in Bidhannagar. For smooth execution and legal compliance, it is strongly advised to consult experienced property lawyers familiar with Salt Lake’s unique lease framework.Need Legal Assistance for Salt Lake Property Transfers?At KHA ADVOCATES, our dedicated legal team provides expert assistance for lease deed reviews, mutation, registration, and title verification in Bidhannagar. Contact us today for a hassle-free consultation.📞 Call Now 94-777-5-888-5 | 🌐 Visit www.khaadvocates.comRelevant Links:Circular https://www.wburbanservices.gov.in/upload_file/circular/1721-ud.pdf2012 notification https://www.wburbanservices.gov.in/upload_file/file_doc/al_2709_3377.pdf88 Plots https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kolkata/salt-lake-plot-transfer-begins-again/articleshow/53470533.cms
Read MoreA: We offer end-to-end legal support including land due diligence, joint venture agreements, RERA compliance, project approvals, dispute resolution, and documentation.
A: Legal due diligence ensures clear title, absence of encumbrances, and identifies any risks that can impact project execution or sales.
A: Yes, we assist in land acquisition, verification, title searches, and obtaining government permissions for development.
A: Absolutely. We specialize in drafting, reviewing, and negotiating JDAs, ensuring clarity on profit-sharing, rights, and obligations.
A: RERA is the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act. We help with RERA registration, documentation, and compliance to avoid penalties and legal disputes.
A: Yes, we handle all legal processes involved in land use conversion, including liaison with authorities and necessary approvals.
A: Yes, we represent developers in consumer court cases, RERA tribunals, civil suits, and arbitration relating to property and construction disputes.
A: Yes, we draft and vet sale agreements, builder-buyer agreements, and allotment letters to ensure they’re legally enforceable and compliant with law.
A: Definitely. We prepare construction contracts, sub-contractor MoUs, supplier agreements, and ensure risk mitigation.
A: We defend such claims and help resolve them through legal negotiation, arbitration, or representation before RERA and consumer forums.
A: Yes, we guide through the legal process of securing sanction plans, environment clearances, and urban development approvals.
A: Yes. We offer mediation, arbitration, and litigation support in case of conflicts in joint development or revenue-sharing models.
A: A PoA authorizes a party to act on behalf of another in transactions. We draft and register legally valid PoAs for property-related actions.
A: Yes, and we help draft NRI-friendly contracts, manage FEMA compliance, and protect overseas investors’ rights in Indian real estate ventures.
A: Yes, we handle all backend legal work like mutation, khatian corrections, and revenue record compliance.
A: We help resolve title disputes through court proceedings, partition suits, or legal clearance, ensuring clean title before development.
A: Yes, we conduct thorough legal audits of ongoing or upcoming projects to ensure compliance and legal security.
A: We represent developers in cases where homebuyers challenge refund clauses, delays, or defects in the construction.
A: Yes, especially post-RERA, registration is mandatory in most cases. We ensure proper drafting and registration as per law.
A: Because we combine deep legal expertise with a business-minded approach, ensuring your project is legally sound, dispute-free, and profit-optimized.
Could discuss my case in length. Useful advice was provided to me. I would like to recommend.
I have visited for NOC & declaration matter. Personally i think Mr. Kabir is very professional & very positive minded.
Very professional, on time and Technically good. We are extremely Satisfied with my apartment registration.
Excellent service, on time, technically efficient. We are very happy with the service provided. Thanks a lot.
Very loyal, I am very happy with his service, he is understanding, mature and very knowledgeable,any kind of problem he can solve
I was greatly relieved after talking to Advocate Kabir Hassan. I needed a clarification about the proceedings of my Talak with my current lawyer and Mr. Hassan confirmed with valid points. Thank you, again!
Very professional and very kind hearted person i have ever visited. Very helpfull in nature and one of the best lawyer's in my locality.
Very knowledgeable having a Positive Attitude towards client's problems, All the staffs are also helpful. Satisfied with their services.
It's an awasome place to resolved your legal issue...specially kabir sir is very good and honest person to solve your query step by step. Thanks to kha advocate for helping my legal issue..
One of the best experienced and professional advocate i have ever seen. Please do visit and consult with him. He is the best person to get rid you off from each and every law related problems.
it waa good experiance with KHA advocate for my hassle free registration. I highly recomend other to consult for any property related or legal matters with KHA thanks Anant Pradhan.
Having excellent analytical and logical approach is the hallmark in Law Firm. As per my convenience, I truly appreciate that KHA Sir take the time to talk to me. I express my gratitude to KHA for their help and support.
Very courteous, professional and competent law firm led by the able Mr. Kabir Hassan. They handled the searching, sale agreement / deed drafting, query generation / stamp duty payment and registration process of my new flat in New Town very, very smoothly despite several challenges / issues from the seller's end along the way.
Service provided by him was good. He is very polite, knowledgeable and helpful. He guided through our case very well.
KhA Advocates is a premier law firm in Kolkata, West Bengal known Internationally, providing expert legal services in property registration, corporate law, matrimonial law, taxation, dispute resolution, and more. We offer tailored legal solutions for NRIs, businesses, and residents, ensuring 100% compliance and protection. With our efficient, transparent, and reliable approach, we safeguard your legal interests.
Highly recommended for Divorce case. I got Divorce order so fast than my expectation. Thanks a lot Mr. Kabir
Shreyasi Chakrabarty